Problem statement
1. For the Church: Membership has been in decline; member contributions are currently insufficient for the long-term viability of the church. We don't have a plan for reversing that trend.
2. For musicians: Forming a band has become nearly impossible. Even if a band manages to achieve critical success and build a following, TicketMaster and ConcertMaster have turned touring into a losing proposition for everyone involved: bands, fans, and venues. The only people getting paid are capitalists–people who have no connection at all to the music.
The Proposal
Guidelines and Requirements
We're still in the sanctuary of the house we built for God. All programming needs to be aligned with that.
Sunday morning is an especially sacred service, in the sense that it is the most established and has the most tradition around it.
We cannot compete in the field of contemporary Christian rock or “Praise and Worship” music and we should not try.
The director needs to be a complete hardass. Musicians that don't show up early don't get called back.
Four shows in one weekend is a lot of playing. We must take care not to overdo it.
Use of a drumkit is not a pathway to success. It MIGHT be an indicator of success.
All parties must follow copyright law. Ownership of any recordings must be negotiated before the church invests musical resources.
Selection of music is 100% up to the church. We invite and welcome suggestions.
New compositions specifically for these services must be collaborative. If there is an artistic disagreement, we make two versions of the song: a version reflecting the artistic preferences of the church music program, and another reflecting the band's preferences.
Strengths and Opportunities
Weaknesses and Pitfalls
First and foremost, this is a massive undertaking with many points of potential failure. We absolutely need more volunteers.
“Fair pay” is likely to become contentious. I recommend a base rate for singers, a higher base rate for instrumentalists, and a percentage of plate offerings for services played. (I can already hear daggers…)
Our A/V system, while capable, needs some development.
The amount of preparation we currently put into services will not be adequate.